Customers Don’t Always Know What They Want (But You Still Need to Listen)

👂 How to extract actionable insight from fuzzy feedback.
Myth: Just build what customers ask for.
Reality: Dig deeper to understand the real problem.

---

You just got off a call with a customer who said:

“Can you add a report export button?”

The feature sounds straightforward. The request seems clear. But here’s the catch:

That button might not be what they actually need.

At Smartware Advisors, we’ve worked with countless product teams who are overwhelmed by feature requests—most of them well-intentioned, few of them truly valuable.

The common trap?
✅ Listening to what users ask for…
❌ …without understanding what they actually mean.

Let’s talk about how to turn fuzzy feedback into product clarity—and avoid building the wrong things for the right reasons.

---

🚫 Why “Just Build What They Ask For” Doesn’t Work

Customers experience the product from their own lens.
They’re focused on tasks, not your roadmap.

When they ask for a specific feature, what they’re often trying to say is:

• “I’m stuck.”

• “This is harder than it should be.”

• “I’m trying to do X, but can’t figure out how.”

The result?
They suggest solutions rather than describing the problem.

If you take the request at face value and build exactly what they asked for:
❌ You may add unnecessary complexity
❌ You might solve a symptom, not the cause
❌ You’ll build for one user instead of many

💡 Your job as a PM isn’t to take orders—it’s to uncover truth.

---

🧠 What Great PMs Do Instead

The best product managers listen closely—but probe deeply.

They use every feature request, complaint, or vague idea as a jumping-off point to find out what the customer is really trying to achieve.

---

✅ Step 1: Ask “Why?” (Then Ask It Again)

Don’t stop at the surface request. Ask:

• Why do you need that?

• What are you trying to do?

• What happens if you don’t have it?

• How are you doing this today?

By the second or third “why,” you’ll often discover:
🧠 A workaround they didn’t mention
🧠 A pain point affecting more users
🧠 A better way to solve the same problem

💡 The feature they asked for is often just a symptom.

---

✅ Step 2: Look for Patterns, Not One-Offs

Just because one user wants something doesn’t mean everyone does.

Instead of building immediately:

• Review similar feedback from other users

• Tag themes in support tickets

• Check usage data—are others struggling with the same thing?

💡 A strong signal is when multiple users describe the same problem—even if they ask for different solutions.

---

✅ Step 3: Validate With Behavior, Not Just Words

What customers say and what they do aren’t always aligned.

Use product analytics to:

• See where users drop off or stall

• Track low engagement with existing features

• Identify repeat behaviors that indicate unmet needs

💡 Pair qualitative feedback with behavioral data for a full picture.

---

✅ Step 4: Reframe the Problem Before You Build

Before turning feedback into a roadmap item, write it up as a problem statement, not a feature request.

Example:
❌ “Add an export button for reports”
✅ “Users need an easier way to share key insights with their team”

This invites collaboration with design and engineering—and opens the door for better solutions.

💡 Solving the right problem matters more than building the requested feature.

---

🚀 Final Thought: Be a Listener, Not an Order-Taker

Customers are full of valuable insight—but they rarely hand it to you clearly.
That’s your job.

You’re not just building what people say they want.
You’re building what helps them succeed—even if they don’t know how to ask for it.

At Smartware Advisors, we teach PMs how to translate feedback into real product strategy—so they deliver solutions that matter, not just features that fill the backlog.

---

TL;DR – Listening vs. Building on Demand

👂 Customers describe symptoms
🧠 PMs uncover root problems
📊 Combine feedback with usage data
✏️ Reframe requests into problem statements
🚫 Don’t just build faster—build smarter

Always listen. But listen like a detective, not a delivery service.

Need help evaluating where you stand? Let’s talk.

Reach out to Smartware Advisors for a free consultation  https://calendly.com/waqar-hashim.

#productmanagement #customerfeedback #problemsolving #productstrategy #smartwareadvisors #buildwithclarity